Counselling Online & Horsham, Amanda Randall

I support people in making sense of feeling stuck, lost and uncertain, and in discovering what matters most.


Outgrowing Your Old Life: Understanding Midlife Change

You Can Outgrow a Life Without Having Done Anything Wrong

When something big happens or changes in your life it can sometimes make us look at ourselves and assume we got something wrong. 

You can look back at the choices you’ve made, the things you’ve put up with, the opportunities you didn’t take and the things you wish you’d done differently. You start asking yourself questions. Did I get it wrong? Should I have done something differently? Have I wasted time? 

It can feel as though, if you want something different now, it must mean that something was wrong with what you chose before. 

I know how that feels.  There have been some absolutely brilliant times in my HR career. I’ve met incredible people, had exciting opportunities, and learnt so much about myself and others. I didn’t leave that part of my life behind because I regretted it. I left because it was time to do something new. I wasn’t the same person, and I didn’t want the same things. 

I know that now. But when I was in the thick of it, I struggled with lots of conflicting feelings, including one particularly persistent question: Did I do something wrong?

When change starts to feel like failure 

We can often think about life in a linear way, we make a choice, follow a path and expect to keep going in the same direction. If we decide to change course, it can feel as though we must have made a mistake somewhere along the way. 

There might be a little fear in there, too. Because looking honestly at what you want and recognising that it might mean changing something can be really scary. 

Sometimes it feels safer to leave things as they are. You can tell yourself, “I chose this, so I have to live with it now,” rather than face the possibility of getting something wrong. 

The past feels familiar but the next chapter really doesn’t.  While you’re busy working out where you went wrong, you don’t have to think too much about what you might want now or what changing things might mean. 

But what if wanting something different doesn’t mean you got it wrong in the first place? 

One of the things my counselling training has taught me is that two things that seem opposite can both be true. 

I can have chosen the life I wanted then and enjoyed it AND I can want something different now.  Both of these things can be true. 

I don’t have to regret the time I spent in corporate HR to recognise that I no longer want to work in it. I don’t have to rewrite my past as a mistake to make sense of my future. 

What I needed and wanted before may not be what I need and want now. And that’s OK. 

Sometimes things change. We change. What we need changes, too.  You can outgrow a life without having done anything wrong. 

But who am I without the job or role I know? 

Perhaps the easiest way to describe this feeling is to think about meeting someone new. 

After they know your name, one of the first things they’re likely to ask is, “And what do you do?”   You may have given the same answer for years.  For me, it was, “Oh, I work in People. Yeah, that used to be called HR.”  Then I’d wait for the inevitable, “Shh, everyone, HR is in the room!” and have my responses ready.  It was a predictable, well-rehearsed routine. 

Then I didn’t “do” HR anymore, but I couldn’t quite let it go. My answer became, “Oh, I’m a student, but I used to work in HR.”  I didn’t really know who I was without that label because it had become such a big part of my identity.    I’d made it that way, and the society we live in makes what we “do” an important part of describing who we are.  

But is what we "do" really who we are?

During my counselling training, we did an exercise where we had to answer not “What do you do?” but “Who are you?” 

I sat there with no clue what to say. 

Try it. Answer the question: Who are you? 

I can’t even remember what I said in that class, but the exercise shifted how I thought about my identity. I began to see that who I am is not just the job or role I have. It’s a lot more than that.  I’m curious (nosey), creative (but I can’t draw), empathetic and determined (stubborn).  There’s more, but I still find it very hard to be a self-deprecating Brit and say these things about myself. 

It might be a bit weird to answer a new contact’s question about what you do with a list of who you are. But recognising that we are more than our job title can give us some breathing space.  If we are more than our role, we take away some of the power it has over us.  Perhaps that makes it a little easier to imagine doing something different.  Because if our identity is tied too tightly to what we do, changing what we do can feel like losing who we are. 

My brain loves a bit of overthinking 

Of course, recognising that you want something different doesn’t necessarily mean you can calmly accept it and move on. 

My brain loves to go into overdrive overthinking a specific moment or conversation. It could be something from ten years ago that pops up at 3 am, or it could be something I’m preparing for that hasn’t even happened yet. 

I have always been really good at overthinking.  I’ve tried to fight it, stop it and be cross with my stupid brain for torturing me in this way. 

I like to get things right and be prepared for anything. It sounds obvious now, but before counselling, I’d never connected these things with my overthinking.  There was, of course, lots of work I did in counselling to understand where this need to be prepared and get things right comes from. But that’s not for a blog post! 

What I did begin to understand was that I had fed this overthinking, which wanted me to get everything right, through many years in a corporate HR career that always pushed me to do more and better.   

Connecting my need for perfection with my overthinking has helped me see it differently.  Instead of seeing my overthinking as something my brain does to punish me, I can begin to see it as something I do to try to prepare and protect myself.  Perhaps my overthinking is something I learnt to do to help me, not punish me.   

That small shift has made a difference. 

I’m less angry with my “stupid brain” when I can recognise what it might be trying to do for me. I can understand that it’s attempting to keep me safe, even if its methods aren’t always particularly helpful.   

I’ll probably always think about things that others may not, and I’ll probably always be a little overprepared. But maybe that’s OK. It’s just how I’ve learnt to look out for myself. 

When I can see it like that, I can be kinder to myself. 

I can step back and remember that I don’t have to have every detail figured out. I can trust myself to find a way and know what to do next. 

Or, if I find myself replaying something that happened in the past, I can remind myself that it was OK. Perhaps not perfect, but OK.  And OK is OK, sometimes.  The world kept turning. 

A little moment of “aha” 

Counselling can be like that.  Taking the time to slow down and talk to someone can sometimes offer a moment when you suddenly see something about yourself differently. 

Nothing about the past has changed. You haven’t erased an experience or undone a decision. But the way you understand it shifts, and that can change how you feel about yourself. 

I was trying to explain this to someone, and they said, “Oh, it’s a bit like learning to do a deadlift. A PT offers a slight adjustment and you can lift the bigger weight.”  I rather like that analogy. 

The weight hasn’t necessarily changed. You haven’t suddenly become a different person. But a small adjustment in how you approach it can make something feel more manageable.  Perhaps the same is true when we think about change. 

We don’t always need to go back and decide that everything we did before was wrong.  

We might just need to look at it from a slightly different angle.  Instead of asking, “Why did I spend so long doing that?” we could ask, “Was Ii enjoying that, then” 

Instead of asking, “Why didn’t I change sooner?” we could ask, “Could something about me and what i want have changed?” 

We can be so quick to turn the need for change into a story about failure. We look back at the choices we made with the knowledge and perspective we have now, forgetting that we made those choices with what we knew we wanted and needed back then. 

You might have chosen a career that suited you brilliantly back then and you loved it (well mostly loved it).  Now you might want something else. 

Rather than failing, it might mean that you’ve learnt something new about yourself. Maybe you have grown or your priorities have shifted or things around you have changed and its made you want something different.  

You don’t have to regret what came before to want something different now and you don't have to have it all figured out on your own.  Sometimes the most helpful thing we can do is pause and give ourselves some space to recognise that everything changes, the world and people around us are always changing.   We are also allowed to change and we don't have to figure it out alone.

Written by Amanda Randall, BACP registered counsellor, offering person-centred counselling online throughout the UK and in person in Horsham, West Sussex.

enjoying time with my dog on a beautiful morning walk

©Counselling Therapy with Amanda

powered by WebHealer | GDPR & Cookie Policies